Bourbon Maple Cream: A Velvety, Sweet, and Spiced Holiday Cocktail

Introduction Bourbon Maple Cream

When the temperatures drop and the nights grow longer, your drink menu needs to shift into comfort mode. And nothing says cozy quite like a cocktail made with bourbon, cream, and real maple syrup. Say hello to the Bourbon Maple Cream—a short, rich, winter-ready sipper that feels like a warm blanket (even when served cold).

This creamy cocktail delivers the sweetness of maple, the boozy punch of bourbon, and the decadent texture of heavy cream, all tied together with a dusting of cinnamon on top. It’s incredibly simple—only three ingredients plus a garnish—but it tastes like something you’d get at a fancy cocktail bar around the holidays.

Whether you’re curling up by the fire or looking for a low-effort, high-reward drink to impress your guests, this one is worth shaking up.

What Is the Bourbon Maple Cream?

The Bourbon Maple Cream is an indulgent holiday cocktail that blends strong, sweet, and creamy into one luxurious drink. It’s perfect for sipping slowly, especially after dinner or as a dessert replacement.

Think of it as a simplified version of eggnog—with fewer ingredients and no eggs—but just as satisfying. The maple syrup adds depth, the cream adds body, and the bourbon adds backbone.

This isn’t your average bourbon cocktail. It’s dessert in a glass—with an adult twist.

Flavor Profile: Sweet, Boozy, Creamy, and Comforting

Here’s what happens in your mouth with each sip:

• First taste: Sweet, velvety maple syrup melts into your tongue.
• Mid-palate: The rich bourbon kicks in, warming your chest without overwhelming the sweetness.
• Finish: Creamy texture lingers, with a final hint of spice from the cinnamon garnish.

It’s not too strong, but it’s definitely not mild. It walks the perfect line between comfort and kick.

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Why It Works as a Winter Drink

This cocktail feels like it was made for cold nights, cozy sweaters, and soft blankets. The creaminess makes it feel rich, while the maple and bourbon bring in those deep, warm notes we crave in winter.

It’s the kind of cocktail that makes you pause and enjoy the moment—ideal for sipping slowly while watching snow fall or catching up with friends after dinner.

Ingredient Breakdown

Let’s break down what makes the Bourbon Maple Cream so effortlessly delicious. With only three main ingredients, each one plays a major role in creating the cocktail’s flavor, texture, and overall experience.

Bourbon: The Heart of the Drink

If cream is the soul, then bourbon is the backbone. It’s the spirit that gives this cocktail its depth, warmth, and strength. Not just any whiskey will do—bourbon, with its natural vanilla, caramel, and oak notes, pairs perfectly with maple and cream.

Best Bourbons for This Drink:

• Buffalo Trace – Smooth, rich, and not too overpowering
• Bulleit Bourbon – A little spicier, which cuts through the cream nicely
• Woodford Reserve – Slightly nutty with warm baking spice notes
• Maker’s Mark – Buttery and sweet, excellent for dessert-style cocktails

Choose a bourbon that’s smooth and balanced, not overly smoky or high-proof. You want it to blend with the cream, not dominate it.

Maple Syrup: Sweetness with Depth

Maple syrup brings not just sweetness, but a complex, earthy richness that’s perfect for cozy, holiday flavors. Unlike simple syrup, which is just sugar and water, maple syrup adds molasses-like depth that makes this cocktail feel warm and comforting.

What Kind to Use:

• Pure maple syrup ONLY. Skip the fake pancake syrup—it’s full of additives and will ruin the texture and taste.
• Grade A Dark Amber or Grade B maple syrup adds the most robust flavor.

Just 1 oz is enough to balance the drink, sweeten the cream, and smooth out the bourbon’s bite.

Heavy Cream: Rich and Luxurious Texture

Cream makes this drink feel like a dessert and a nightcap all in one. It gives the Bourbon Maple Cream its name—and its soul. The texture becomes thick, velvety, and luscious with every sip.

Cream Options:

• Heavy cream is ideal. It’s thick, rich, and holds up to shaking without separating.
• Half-and-half can work for a lighter version, but it won’t be as indulgent.
• Plant-based options? Use unsweetened coconut cream or oat-based cream alternatives for a dairy-free version.

Pro tip: Use cold cream, and don’t over-shake, or it might start turning into whipped cream.

Cinnamon: The Perfect Final Touch

Though it’s technically optional, cinnamon adds aroma, warmth, and a visual finish that ties everything together. Just a light dusting is enough to hint at holiday spice without overpowering the rest.

You can use:

• Ground cinnamon – Easy and accessible
• Freshly grated cinnamon stick – Fancier and more fragrant
• Nutmeg or cocoa powder – As alternative or additional garnish

How to Make a Bourbon Maple Cream Cocktail (Step-by-Step)

This cocktail is quick and easy to make—no cooking, no infusing, no complicated steps. Just shake and sip.

Ingredients:

• 2 oz bourbon
• 1 oz pure maple syrup
• 2 oz heavy cream
• Ice
• Ground cinnamon (for garnish)

Instructions:

1. Add all ingredients to a cocktail shaker:
   • Pour bourbon, maple syrup, and heavy cream into your shaker.
   • Add a scoop of ice—just enough to chill and slightly dilute.
2. Shake well—but not too long:
   • Shake for 10–12 seconds. You want everything blended and chilled, but not whipped.
3. Strain into a rocks glass:
   • No need to add fresh ice unless you like your drink colder longer.
   • A single large cube can keep it chilled without watering it down too fast.
4. Garnish:
   • Lightly dust the top with ground cinnamon.
   • Want to be extra? Add a cinnamon stick or star anise pod.
5. Sip slowly and enjoy:
   • This is a cocktail meant to be savored, not slammed. Treat it like dessert in a glass.

Glassware & Presentation

Presentation matters—especially with a cocktail that’s as rich and inviting as the Bourbon Maple Cream. The right glass not only makes the drink look elegant, but it also complements the drink’s texture and mood.

Best Glassware Options:

• Rocks glass (a.k.a. old fashioned glass):
  This is the go-to. Short, sturdy, and ideal for sipping slowly.
• Nick and Nora or coupe glass:
  For a classier, vintage feel. No ice needed—just strain and serve.
• Small holiday mugs or crystal tumblers:
  If you’re going festive, go all the way. Great for cozying up in front of the fire.

Make sure your glass is chilled or at least room temperature. Since this drink is served cold, a warm glass can dull the experience.

Optional Touches:

• Add a sugar or cinnamon sugar rim for a dessert-like feel.
• Float a toasted marshmallow or mini biscotti on the rim for presentation and snacking.

Serving Temperature: Cold and Creamy

Though rich and cozy, this drink is not meant to be served warm like a hot toddy. Why?

• Shaking it with ice dilutes it just slightly, cutting the richness of the cream and the heat of the bourbon.
• A cold serving temperature keeps the texture smooth, like an iced coffee meets cocktail.
• It’s more refreshing and balanced—perfect after a hot, heavy meal.

If you’re craving warmth, this might not be the drink. But if you want to end your evening with something indulgent and silky, this chilled beauty is the move.

Garnish & Extra Toppings

Sure, cinnamon dust is great—but you can dress this cocktail up even more if you’re feeling creative.

Garnish Ideas:

• Cinnamon stick – Stirring tool and aromatic bonus
• Grated nutmeg – A warm, woodsy note
• Shaved chocolate or cocoa powder – For a dessert-forward version
• Crushed candied pecans – For a bit of texture on top
• Whipped cream – Yes, it turns into a boozy dessert fast

Treat this like you would a holiday latte or creamy dessert cocktail—the garnish is the final love letter to your tastebuds.

Make It for a Crowd

Want to serve this at a party? It’s surprisingly easy to batch in advance.

Batch Recipe for 6–8 Servings:

• 2 cups bourbon
• 1 cup pure maple syrup
• 2 cups heavy cream

Instructions:

1. Mix all ingredients in a large pitcher or jug.
2. Stir or whisk until fully blended.
3. Chill in the fridge until ready to serve.
4. Shake individual servings with ice before pouring into glasses.
5. Garnish each glass with cinnamon just before serving.

Important: Don’t add ice to the pitcher—it’ll water it down. Always shake per serving for best texture.

Creative Variations

Want to experiment a little? Here are some ways to remix the Bourbon Maple Cream to match different tastes and dietary needs.

1. Maple Coffee Cream

• Add 0.5 oz coffee liqueur (like Kahlúa or Mr. Black)
• Turns it into a caffeinated dessert cocktail—perfect for brunch or after dinner.

2. Vegan Bourbon Maple Cream

• Replace heavy cream with unsweetened coconut cream or oat-based creamer.
• Make sure your maple syrup is pure, not honey-blended.

3. Spiced Bourbon Cream

• Add a few drops of bitters (aromatic or orange) before shaking.
• Balances sweetness with complexity.

4. Smoky Bourbon Cream

• Use a smoky bourbon or add a drop of mezcal for a hint of campfire.

5. Boozier Dessert Version

• Top with a float of dark rum for layered flavor.

Perfect Pairings

Because it’s rich and sweet, the Bourbon Maple Cream pairs beautifully with light desserts or salty snacks that contrast the creaminess.

Sweet Pairings:

• Pecan pie
• Chocolate truffles
• Gingerbread cookies
• Maple walnut fudge
• Pumpkin cheesecake

Savory Pairings:

• Sharp cheddar and crackers
• Spiced nuts
• Prosciutto-wrapped dates
• Pretzel bites with mustard dip

This cocktail enhances dessert, but it can also act as dessert all on its own.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Even simple cocktails have some room for error. Don’t let these missteps ruin your bourbon bliss:

❌ Using fake maple syrup

• Always go for real, pure maple syrup. Anything else is too sweet and artificial.

❌ Over-shaking the cream

• Shaking too long can turn it foamy or even start to whip it. 10–12 seconds is plenty.

❌ Choosing harsh bourbon

• High-proof, spicy bourbons can overpower the other flavors. Stick with smooth, mid-range options.

❌ Serving warm

• This drink is meant to be cold. Heating it up makes the cream weird and the flavor too heavy.

❌ Using milk instead of cream

• Milk is too thin and will water the drink down. Heavy cream is key.

When to Serve It

The Bourbon Maple Cream isn’t a party drink in the traditional sense—it’s more of a slow-sipping, end-of-the-night indulgence. It’s perfect for winding down after a big holiday meal or cozying up by the fireplace with friends or a good book.

Perfect Occasions for This Cocktail:

• Christmas Eve or Christmas Night – After presents and pie, this is your nightcap.
• Thanksgiving dessert hour – Especially if pecan or pumpkin pie is involved.
• Cold-weather date nights – Sip by candlelight or fireside.
• Holiday dinner parties – Serve it as a dessert cocktail.
• NYE Wind-Down Drink – When you’re past the bubbly and want something rich.

It’s also great for gift wrapping nights, snowy Sundays, or anytime you want a drink that feels like a hug in a glass.

Conclusion

The Bourbon Maple Cream is proof that simple ingredients, when chosen well, can come together to create something unforgettably luxurious. With its velvety texture, warm bourbon heart, and maple-sweet richness, it’s everything a winter cocktail should be—cozy, comforting, and celebratory.

Whether you’re looking for a new holiday tradition, a fireside nightcap, or just something to sip that tastes like a grown-up dessert, this cocktail checks all the boxes.

It’s not fussy, it’s not over-complicated, and it delivers serious seasonal charm in every sip. Shake one up, sprinkle some cinnamon on top, and toast to all things warm and wonderful.

FAQs

1. Can I use a different spirit instead of bourbon?
Yes, you can swap in dark rum, Irish whiskey, or even brandy for a similar richness. Just note the flavor profile will shift.

2. Can I make it ahead of time?
Absolutely! You can pre-mix the bourbon, maple syrup, and cream and store it in the fridge. Shake individual servings with ice before pouring.

3. Do I have to shake it, or can I just stir?
You really should shake it. Shaking chills the drink, blends the cream, and slightly aerates it for a smooth mouthfeel. Stirring just won’t cut it.

4. What type of maple syrup is best?
Go for pure, dark amber maple syrup—Grade A or B. The darker the syrup, the more robust and complex the flavor.

5. Can I serve it warm?
Technically, yes—but it’s not ideal. Warming cream can cause it to curdle or separate with alcohol. This cocktail shines when served cold and creamy.

Print