Name: New York Bakery-Style Sicilian Pizza
Prep time: 15 min
Cook time: 20 min
Total time: 35 min
Cuisine: Italian
Ingredients: 2 cups all-purpose flour; 1 cup warm water (about 110°F); 1 packet active dry yeast; 1 tablespoon sugar; 1 teaspoon salt; 2 tablespoons olive oil; 1 cup rich tomato sauce; 2 cups shredded mozzarella cheese; 1 teaspoon dried oregano; 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder

New York Bakery-Style Sicilian pizza slice with cheese and toppings

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

The moment you pull a square pan of New York bakery–style Sicilian pizza from the oven, your kitchen fills with a heady, irresistible perfume: warm olive oil, toasted crust, and sweet tomato simmered until silky. The top crackles under a golden blanket of bubbling mozzarella, and when you press a fingertip to the edge, the interior gives way to a soft, airy crumb that practically sighs with buttered richness. This is pizza built for spooning up conversations as much as slices—chewy, tender, and unapologetically comforting.

Every bite contrasts textures in the most satisfying way: the first mouthful offers a light crunch from the raised corners, then yields to a pillowy, olive-oil-scented crumb, followed by the creamy pull of cheese and a bright, tangy tomato note that lingers. If you love pan pizzas, you might also enjoy my take on a smoky topping in this BBQ Chicken Flatbread Pizza recipe, but this Sicilian keeps things classically simple—centering brilliant dough and sauce so each element sings.

Why You’ll Love This New York Bakery-Style Sicilian Pizza

This version marries New York sensibility with Sicilian soul. The dough rises in a way that creates lofty pockets and a sturdy base, so it holds toppings without collapsing. You’ll notice a light, almost brioche-like crumb on the inside, kissed by olive oil, while the bottom and edges crisp to the kind of golden brown that begs for a crunchy first bite.

It shines at casual gatherings—slice it thick for family-style sharing, or cut into squares for a party platter that travels well. It stands out because every component pulls double duty: simple tomato sauce brightens while keeping the pie moist, and a modest hit of dried oregano and garlic powder provides an aromatic backdrop that makes this feel like a familiar neighborhood bakery loaf rather than an overly fussy dinner.

Preparation Phase & Tools to Use

Getting the best results depends as much on tools and prep as the recipe itself. Here’s what matters:

A large mixing bowl: Give your dough plenty of elbow room to rise. Glass or stainless steel works well so you can see the dough double.
Measuring cups and a kitchen scale (optional but recommended): Flour weight yields more consistent dough than cups, but cups work fine if you spoon and level.
A sturdy baking pan (9×13-inch recommended): Traditional Sicilian pizza bakes in a well-oiled rectangular pan so the crust crisps evenly and edges caramelize.
A dough scraper or bench knife: Makes kneading and transferring dough cleaner and faster.
A damp towel or plastic wrap: Keeps the dough from forming a crust during its rise.
A decent oven thermometer: Home ovens can run hot or cold; accurate temperature ensures the crust crisps without burning.

Practical preparation tips:

Warm water should feel like a cozy bath (about 110°F / 43°C). Too hot kills yeast; too cool slows it down.
Lightly oil the pan—not just to prevent sticking, but to help the dough crisp and flavor the bottom crust.
Prepare your sauce and shred cheese ahead so topping assembly feels effortless once the dough has rested.

Ingredients for New York Bakery-Style Sicilian Pizza

2 cups all-purpose flour
1 cup warm water (about 110°F)
1 packet active dry yeast
1 tablespoon sugar
1 teaspoon salt
2 tablespoons olive oil
1 cup rich tomato sauce
2 cups shredded mozzarella cheese
1 teaspoon dried oregano
1/2 teaspoon garlic powder

Key ingredient notes and substitutions:

Flour: All-purpose works well here and creates a soft crumb; for a chewier, slightly more complex flavor, swap half for bread flour. If you need gluten-free, use a 1:1 gluten-free blend and follow package notes for hydration.
Yeast: Active dry yeast rehydrates in warm water; instant yeast can be mixed straight into flour (use about 3/4 packet).
Olive oil: Adds flavor and a tender crumb. You can use melted butter for a richer flavor, but the crust loses some of its characteristic chew.
Tomato sauce: Use a robust, slightly sweet sauce—homemade or a high-quality canned passata works best. For a herbed twist, mix in a touch of fresh basil.
Cheese: Whole-milk mozzarella gives better melt and creaminess. For extra flavor, blend in 1/2 cup grated Pecorino or Parmesan.
Seasonings: Dried oregano and garlic powder are classic; swap garlic powder for a clove of minced fresh garlic if you’d like a punchier aroma.

How to Make New York Bakery-Style Sicilian Pizza

Follow these steps for a reliable, bakery-style result. Small tips appear inline to help at critical moments.

Activate the yeast.
- In a small bowl, stir 1 cup warm water with 1 tablespoon sugar and the packet of active dry yeast. Let sit 5–10 minutes until frothy and fragrant. If it doesn’t foam, the yeast may be old—start over with fresh yeast.
Mix the dough.
- In a large mixing bowl, combine 2 cups all-purpose flour and 1 teaspoon salt. Make a well in the center and pour in the yeast mixture and 2 tablespoons olive oil. Stir until a shaggy dough forms.
- Tip: If the dough feels too dry, add water 1 teaspoon at a time; if too sticky, add a dusting of flour.
Knead until smooth.
- Turn the dough onto a lightly floured surface and knead for 5–7 minutes until smooth and elastic. The dough should bounce back when pressed.
- Tip: Use a bench scraper for sticky dough to avoid adding too much extra flour.
First rise.
- Lightly oil a bowl, place the dough inside, and turn once to coat. Cover with a damp cloth or plastic wrap and let rise in a warm spot for about 1 hour, or until doubled in size.
- Tip: An oven with the light on creates a gently warm environment ideal for rising.
Preheat the oven.
- Preheat your oven to 475°F (245°C) while the dough is rising or during the last 10 minutes of the rise.
Shape the dough in the pan.
- Punch down the risen dough and turn it into a greased 9×13-inch baking pan. Press the dough out to the corners using your fingertips and the flats of your hands. The dough will spring back slightly—keep pressing until it reaches the edges.
- Tip: Dimple the surface with your fingertips to create little wells that hold sauce and oil.
Relax the dough.
- Let the dough rest in the pan for an additional 20 minutes to relax and puff slightly. This final rest helps the crumb become airy.
Top the pizza.
- Spread 1 cup of rich tomato sauce evenly across the dough, leaving a small border at the edges. Sprinkle 2 cups shredded mozzarella cheese on top, then dust with 1 teaspoon dried oregano and 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder.
- Tip: Don’t overload the sauce; a thin, even layer keeps the crust from becoming soggy.
Bake.
- Bake on the middle rack for 15–20 minutes, until the cheese bubbles and the crust turns a deep golden brown.
- Tip: Rotate the pan halfway through if your oven has hot spots for even browning.
Rest and serve.
- Allow the pizza to cool for 5–10 minutes so the cheese sets slightly. Slice into squares and serve warm.

Chef’s Notes & Helpful Tips

Make-ahead tips:

Dough: After the first rise, refrigerate the dough (well covered) overnight. Bring it to room temperature and press into the pan before the 20-minute rest. This deepens flavor.
Sauce: Make the tomato sauce 2–3 days ahead; flavors meld beautifully and save time on the day you bake.

Cooking alternatives:

Convection oven: Reduce temperature by 25°F and watch closely—the crust will brown faster.
Air fryer: Only suitable for very small, individual square pans; bake at 375°F for shorter time, checking frequently for bubbling cheese.
Stovetop skillet: For one-pan personal pies, press dough into a well-oiled cast-iron skillet, preheat on medium-low for 5–7 minutes, then finish under a broiler to melt the cheese.

Customization ideas:

Add toppings like caramelized onions, roasted peppers, or sautéed mushrooms before baking.
For a peppery edge, sprinkle crushed red pepper flakes over the cheese.
After baking, drizzle a touch of extra-virgin olive oil or garlic-infused oil for richness.
Swap mozzarella for a blend with fontina or provolone for more depth.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Using water that’s too hot or too cold: Too hot kills yeast; too cold prevents activation. Aim for about 110°F.
Over-flouring dough while kneading: Adding too much flour yields a dense, dry crumb. Use just enough to keep the dough manageable.
Skipping the pan oil: The olive oil does more than prevent sticking; it crisps the bottom and flavors the crust.
Over-saucing: A heavy layer of sauce leads to soggy centers. Use an even, thin spread.
Baking at incorrect temperature: Too low and the crust won’t crisp; too high and the edges burn before the inside cooks. Use an oven thermometer if unsure.

What to Serve With New York Bakery-Style Sicilian Pizza

Pairings that elevate every square:

A crisp green salad with lemon vinaigrette — the acidity cuts through the cheese and refreshes the palate.
Garlic knots or focaccia — echo the olive-oil-baked breadiness for a carb-forward feast.
Roasted or grilled vegetables — charred bell peppers and zucchini add smoky sweetness.
Classic antipasto platter — marinated olives, artichokes, and salami make great starters.
Spicy pickled peppers (peperoncini) — a briny, piquant counterpoint to the richness.
A light beer or a medium-bodied red wine like Chianti — both match the tomato acidity and cheesy texture.
Homemade Caesar or chopped Italian salad — hearty greens that pair with dense pizza.
Simple lemon sorbet for dessert — bright and palate-cleansing after a savory meal.

Storage & Reheating Instructions

Refrigerator: Store leftover slices in an airtight container for up to 3–4 days. Place a paper towel on top to absorb excess moisture.
Freezer: Freeze individual slices on a baking sheet until solid, then stack with parchment between slices in a freezer-safe bag for up to 2 months. Thaw overnight in the fridge before reheating.
Reheating (recommended method): Heat a skillet over medium-low, place slice in, cover briefly until the cheese softens, then finish under a hot broiler for 1–2 minutes to re-bubble the cheese and crisp the top.
Reheating (oven method): Preheat oven to 375°F, place pizza on a baking sheet, and bake 8–10 minutes until warmed through and crust rekindles its crunch. Avoid microwaving unless in a pinch—microwaves make the crust chewy and limp.

Estimated Nutrition Information

Approximate per slice (recipe yields about 8 hearty squares):

Calories: ~320 kcal
Fat: ~14 g
Saturated Fat: ~6 g
Carbohydrates: ~34 g
Protein: ~15 g
Sodium: ~520 mg

These values are rough estimates based on common ingredient averages and will vary with cheese type, sauce brand, and slice size. Use a nutrition calculator for precise numbers based on your exact ingredients.

FAQs

How do I know if my yeast is still good?
- Proofing is the quick test: combine the yeast with warm water and a little sugar; within 5–10 minutes it should foam and smell slightly yeasty. Lack of bubbles usually means the yeast is inactive—replace it. Store yeast in the refrigerator or freezer to prolong its life.
Can I make this dough in a stand mixer?
- Absolutely. Use the dough hook on low speed for about 5–7 minutes until the dough pulls cleanly away from bowl sides and feels elastic. Don’t overmix—stop once the dough is smooth and slightly tacky.
My crust turned out soggy—what went wrong?
- Common causes: too much sauce, insufficient oven heat, underbaked time, or not oiling the pan enough. Bake on the middle rack at the correct temperature, and use a thin sauce layer. If your oven runs cool, give it time to preheat fully and consider a slightly longer bake.
Can I double the recipe for a larger pan or two pans?
- Yes. Double all ingredients and split between two pans for larger gatherings. Make sure both pans have space in the oven for even airflow, or bake them one at a time.
Is there a way to get an extra-crispy bottom without burning the edges?
- Try placing a preheated baking stone or heavy-duty baking sheet on the lower rack while preheating. Transfer the oiled pan onto that hot surface to give the base an aggressive initial blast of heat. Watch closely and rotate if needed.
Can I use fresh mozzarella?
- Fresh mozzarella adds creaminess but contains more moisture, which can lead to a wetter pizza. If using fresh, pat it dry with paper towels and slice thinly. Mixing fresh with shredded low-moisture mozzarella balances melt and moisture control.
How do I get those airy pockets in the crumb?
- Gentle handling after the first rise preserves the gas bubbles. When pressing into the pan, avoid overworking; let the dough relax. Proper yeast activation and warm rises also help create loft.

Conclusion

This New York bakery–style Sicilian pizza brings bakery comfort straight to your kitchen: a tender, olive-oil-scented crumb, a satisfyingly crisp bottom, and a melty, fragrant cheese-top that makes every square feel special. It rewards patience in rising and a light hand in topping—then gives you back big, heartwarming flavor. For a spicy pepperoni spin and additional technique inspiration, try the Sicilian Pizza With Pepperoni and Spicy Tomato Sauce Recipe. Enjoy the way this pan pizza fills a room with aroma and a table with smiles.

Hi, I’m Clara!

I'm a food lover and a firm believer that anyone can learn to cook with a little curiosity and courage. My story with food didn’t begin in a tiny apartment with a two-burner stove and a stack of cookbooks from the local library. I was broke and desperate to make something anything that felt like home.

About Me